The council's auditor says Lichfield District Council did not get timely figures on the cinema joint venture before £3.7m of extra costs emerged. Councillors discuss it on 24 November.

Lichfield District Council’s external auditor has found a “significant weakness” in how the council oversaw the joint venture building the city’s new cinema.

The finding is in the Auditor’s Annual Report for 2025/26 by Azets. It goes to the council’s audit committee on Tuesday 24 November at 6pm.

The auditor says the council did not receive timely financial information from its commercial partner. It says the extra costs were not quantified and passed to the council until June 2026.

Overview

  • What was found: a significant weakness in governance, covering budget control and the flow of information on the cinema joint venture.
  • The money: in July 2026 councillors approved an extra £5.56m, made up of £2.84m of cost pressures and £2.72m to buy out the commercial partner early.
  • What it is not: the auditor has not issued a public interest report, statutory recommendations or an advisory notice.
  • Next: the audit committee meets on Tuesday 24 November at 6pm.

The joint venture

The cinema is being built inside the former Debenhams store at Three Spires. The council set up a joint venture, Darwin Prospects LLP, with a commercial partner to deliver it. The council approved the arrangement in October 2022, and the LLP was set up on 19 October 2023.

The two sides share costs, income and risk 50:50. The commercial partner ran the project day to day and was meant to supply the financial figures. The council had three seats on the partnership board: the council leader and two senior officers.

The partnership agreement, signed on 9 February 2024, said the board should meet monthly and get monthly figures comparing budget with actual spend.

What the auditor found

The report says, based on interviews with two of the council’s board members:

  • no board meetings took place before summer 2025, and no budget monitoring figures were supplied
  • after the council leader raised concerns in early summer 2025, meetings stayed infrequent, held only when key decisions were due
  • the partner first said extra money might be needed in February 2026, but did not put a figure on it until June 2026, when it was about £3.7m
  • the partnership agreement required prior written approval for spending outside the budget, and the auditor understands this did not happen
  • two of the council’s board members had not seen the full partnership agreement or the legal summary of it

The auditor also says there was “an over reliance on the lead senior officer” to manage the relationship with the partner. That officer, it says, relied on informal working relationships rather than the governance set out in the agreement. Updates to Cabinet members were informal, and “no documents are available to substantiate this.”

The report accepts that the council is a small authority with few senior officers to put on such a board.

What the council has done since

The auditor says the council’s actions since it learned of the extra costs show “appropriate due diligence and independent challenge.” An independent quantity surveyor found the overspends reasonable, given changes to the specification and market pressures. The council now gets more frequent updates.

But the report calls these measures “fundamentally reactive in nature, having been implemented after significant cost pressures had been incurred.”

Bar chart of how the extra £5.56m for the Lichfield cinema project is being paid for: internal borrowing £2.85m, earmarked reserves £2.56m and short-term revenue budgets £0.15m.
Chart by Lichfield Today. Source: Azets, Auditor's Annual Report for Lichfield District Council 2025/26.
Share this chartFacebookWhatsAppX

The July decision is funded by £2,850,000 of internal borrowing, £2,561,320 from earmarked reserves and £150,000 from short-term revenue budgets, the report says.

The auditor’s one key recommendation is that the council should make sure oversight of its partnerships follows the agreed procedures, and that breaches are “robustly challenged”. It also says officers and councillors who sit on such boards should have, or be able to get, the right skills and experience. The space for the council’s management response is blank in the published report.

The rest of the report

The rest of the report is less critical:

  • Azets expects to give the council’s 2025/26 accounts a clean, unqualified opinion.
  • It found no significant weakness in the council’s financial sustainability. The general fund stood at £5.2m at 31 March 2026.
  • The council’s internal auditors, BDO, deferred their own audit of the cinema project to 2026/27.
  • The council’s budget plan assumes net income from the cinema of £100,000 in 2028/29 and £200,000 in 2029/30.

The report says the cinema is expected to open in early spring 2027. Everyman, which will run it, now expects the second half of 2027, as we reported on 15 November.

What it means for you

The cinema is still going ahead, and the extra money has already been approved. The finding is about how the council kept track of public money in a private partnership. The auditor says the arrangements “have not been operating as designed”.

The audit committee meeting on 24 November is open to the public. The papers are on the council’s meeting page.